200+ Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Parties
Halloween gives people an excuse to ask ridiculous questions, and Would You Rather is one of the easiest games to pull out when the candy bowl is already getting attention.
You can play these at a family party, in a classroom, around the dinner table, or while a group is waiting for the next Halloween activity to start. The questions are short enough to read out loud and weird enough to get people arguing about things that will never happen.
There are silly choices, candy dilemmas, costume questions, spooky situations, and a few that are much harder than they look. For younger kids, stick with the candy and costume sections. Older groups can head straight for the spooky and difficult ones.
For more Halloween wording to use around the party, see our Halloween Sayings and Halloween Puns.
Table of Contents
Funny Halloween Would You Rather Questions
These are the quick ones that usually start an argument before the second question.
- Would you rather have pumpkin pie for breakfast or candy corn cereal for a week?
- Would you rather wear a vampire cape to school or witch shoes to work?
- Would you rather sneeze glitter every time you see a pumpkin or hiccup every time you hear a ghost story?
- Would you rather have a tiny skeleton follow you around or a tiny witch give you bad advice?
- Would you rather carve a pumpkin with a spoon or decorate one using only stickers?
- Would you rather have a candy bucket that never gets empty or a costume that never wrinkles?
- Would you rather laugh like a witch or walk like a zombie for the whole night?
- Would you rather find a rubber spider in your bed or a plastic eyeball in your shoe?
- Would you rather eat only orange candy or only black candy on Halloween?
- Would you rather have a ghost as your roommate or a vampire as your neighbor?
- Would you rather your costume squeak with every step or light up every time you blink?
- Would you rather accidentally wear your Halloween costume backward all night or inside out all night?
- Would you rather bob for apples while wearing a cape or eat a donut off a string in costume?
- Would you rather have to say boo before every sentence or trick or treat before every snack?
- Would you rather have a pumpkin for a backpack or a cauldron for a purse?
- Would you rather only be able to talk in spooky movie whispers or dramatic villain voices?
- Would you rather have candy wrappers stuck to your shoes or fake cobwebs stuck in your hair?
- Would you rather get a costume compliment from a witch or a high five from a skeleton?
- Would you rather have your phone case turn into a pumpkin or your headphones turn into tiny bats?
- Would you rather wear a costume made of balloons or one made of wrapping paper?
- Would you rather have to dance every time you hear Halloween music or pose every time someone says pumpkin?
- Would you rather have a pet black cat that judges everyone or a pet bat that steals your snacks?
- Would you rather decorate 100 cupcakes or carve 20 pumpkins?
- Would you rather wear fake vampire teeth for dinner or orange face paint to breakfast?
- Would you rather find a surprise bag of candy in your coat or an extra dessert waiting at home?
- Would you rather have your Halloween playlist start playing at the worst possible moment or your costume catch everyone’s attention?
- Would you rather be in charge of the candy bowl or the costume contest?
- Would you rather spend an hour untangling Halloween lights or a whole afternoon sorting candy?
- Would you rather have a pumpkin that talks or a broom that gives you directions?
- Would you rather be the funniest costume at the party or the one everyone remembers tomorrow?
RELATED: Funny Halloween Quotes
Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Kids
Easy enough for younger players, but there is still plenty here to debate.
- Would you rather be a friendly ghost or a friendly monster?
- Would you rather ride on a broomstick or fly with bat wings?
- Would you rather collect candy door to door or get a giant basket at home?
- Would you rather wear a pumpkin costume or a dinosaur costume?
- Would you rather have a talking pumpkin or a endless candy bag?
- Would you rather live in a colorful haunted house or a giant pumpkin house?
- Would you rather have a talking black cat or a talking owl?
- Would you rather decorate cookies or paint mini pumpkins?
- Would you rather find a secret passage behind a bookshelf or a hidden room under the stairs?
- Would you rather have glow-in-the-dark shoes or glow-in-the-dark pajamas?
- Would you rather trick-or-treat with a witch or a superhero?
- Would you rather have a pet bat that sleeps all day or a pet ghost that tells jokes all night?
- Would you rather turn into a pumpkin for one hour or a ghost for one hour?
- Would you rather have unlimited stickers or unlimited Halloween candy?
- Would you rather make the biggest jack-o’-lantern or the funniest one?
- Would you rather wear a costume you picked yourself or have a friend choose it for you?
- Would you rather go to a Halloween parade or a Halloween party?
- Would you rather have a spooky treasure hunt or a costume dance contest?
- Would you rather eat a giant chocolate bar or a giant box of gummy treats?
- Would you rather sleep in a pumpkin-shaped bed or a castle-shaped bed on Halloween night?
- Would you rather have orange hair for a day or green hair for a day?
- Would you rather meet a friendly mummy or a silly vampire?
- Would you rather make paper bats or paper ghosts?
- Would you rather have a Halloween movie night or a Halloween game night?
- Would you rather get a surprise treat every hour or one huge treat at the end of the night?
- Would you rather have a costume with wings or one with a giant hat?
- Would you rather decorate the front door or your bedroom for Halloween?
- Would you rather be in charge of the pumpkin patch or the candy store?
- Would you rather have a witch’s hat that changes color or shoes that sparkle when you walk?
- Would you rather spend Halloween in a pumpkin patch or a spooky-looking forest?
RELATED: Halloween Chalkboard Quotes
Spooky Halloween Would You Rather Questions
A little creepy, but not the kind of creepy that ruins the party.
- Would you rather hear a door creak by itself or see a curtain move in an empty room?
- Would you rather spend five minutes in a dark hallway or ten minutes in a room full of harmless spiders?
- Would you rather hear footsteps behind you or a strange knock at the window?
- Would you rather see one ghost every night or hear one ghost every morning?
- Would you rather explore a creepy attic or a creepy basement?
- Would you rather find muddy footprints inside the house or a chair that moved overnight?
- Would you rather have a portrait whose eyes seem to follow you or a clock that stops at midnight?
- Would you rather hear a whisper from another room or feel a cold breeze with no open window?
- Would you rather walk through a foggy garden at dusk or a dark hallway with flickering lights?
- Would you rather find a mysterious old key or a locked box with no label?
- Would you rather sleep in a room with a rattling window or a room with a squeaky floorboard?
- Would you rather see a shadow under the door or hear a knock from the closet?
- Would you rather find a dusty book with your name in it or a photograph that you do not remember taking?
- Would you rather have a friendly ghost leave notes around the house or a mysterious cat stare at the same corner every night?
- Would you rather walk past a dark graveyard or an empty carnival after sunset?
- Would you rather hear a music box start playing or a wind chime ring with no wind?
- Would you rather open a door that you know you locked or find a light switched on in an empty room?
- Would you rather be followed by a harmless shadow or hear your name whispered once?
- Would you rather explore a foggy corn maze or an old abandoned-looking barn?
- Would you rather spend Halloween in a house with creaky stairs or a house with flickering lights?
- Would you rather find a ghostly handprint on the mirror or footprints near the front door?
- Would you rather hear a floorboard creak upstairs or the basement door close downstairs?
- Would you rather be stuck in an elevator with spooky music or a hallway with flickering bulbs?
- Would you rather see a candle go out by itself or a curtain move when every window is closed?
- Would you rather hear scratching at the wall or tapping at the glass?
- Would you rather spend a night in a haunted-looking hotel or an old cottage in the woods?
- Would you rather find a room that nobody remembers building or a staircase that seems to have one extra step?
- Would you rather be the first person into a haunted house or the last person out?
- Would you rather hear a laugh from upstairs or footsteps on the porch?
- Would you rather have one spooky mystery to solve or one silly ghost to convince you are friends?
RELATED: Halloween Party Invitation Wording
Halloween Would You Rather Questions About Candy
For anyone who takes the candy bowl very seriously.
- Would you rather have chocolate for every treat or gummy candy for every treat?
- Would you rather give up chocolate for a week or give up candy for a month?
- Would you rather find one giant candy bar or twenty tiny ones?
- Would you rather have a candy bucket that refills by itself or a cookie jar that never empties?
- Would you rather eat only sour candy or only sweet candy on Halloween night?
- Would you rather get your least favorite candy from every house or one amazing treat at the very end?
- Would you rather sort a giant pile of candy or count every piece before bed?
- Would you rather have candy corn on pizza or gummy worms in your popcorn?
- Would you rather trade candy with your best friend or let them choose five pieces from your bucket?
- Would you rather have a chocolate pumpkin or a giant caramel apple?
- Would you rather get candy in a pumpkin bucket or a spooky paper bag?
- Would you rather have one candy you love or ten candies you have never tried?
- Would you rather eat dessert before dinner on Halloween or breakfast candy the next morning?
- Would you rather have a candy room or a cookie room for one night?
- Would you rather be allowed to eat candy for five minutes nonstop or choose one perfect candy bar?
- Would you rather have a bowl of mini chocolate bars or one giant chocolate bar?
- Would you rather invent a new Halloween candy or a new Halloween cookie?
- Would you rather have your favorite candy in a giant size or your second favorite candy in unlimited supply?
- Would you rather get candy from a silly costume or from a spooky-looking house?
- Would you rather have a secret candy stash or know exactly where every treat is hidden?
- Would you rather eat only pumpkin-flavored desserts or only chocolate desserts for Halloween?
- Would you rather win a candy-eating contest or a candy-sorting contest?
- Would you rather have a candy bag that weighs ten pounds or one that is tiny but holds unlimited candy?
- Would you rather find a hidden bowl of candy in the kitchen or a hidden box in the closet?
- Would you rather swap your whole candy bucket for one mystery bag or keep everything you collected?
- Would you rather have a Halloween candy tasting party or a Halloween cookie decorating party?
- Would you rather make your own candy or decorate a giant cake?
- Would you rather have candy shaped like bats or candy shaped like pumpkins?
- Would you rather get one treat every time you say boo or every time you hear a spooky sound?
- Would you rather have a candy bowl guarded by a skeleton or a cookie plate guarded by a witch?
RELATED: Halloween Costume Captions
Halloween Would You Rather Questions About Costumes
Costume decisions are hard. These are harder.
- Would you rather dress as a witch or a vampire?
- Would you rather wear a costume with a giant hat or giant shoes?
- Would you rather have a homemade costume or one nobody else can buy?
- Would you rather dress as a spooky character or a ridiculous one?
- Would you rather wear face paint or a full mask?
- Would you rather have a costume with wings or a cape?
- Would you rather be the only person in your costume or match your whole group?
- Would you rather dress up as your favorite animal or your favorite movie character?
- Would you rather wear a costume that glows or one that changes color?
- Would you rather have a costume that takes five minutes to put on or one that takes an hour?
- Would you rather wear a costume with a giant pumpkin head or giant bat wings?
- Would you rather dress as a ghost or a skeleton?
- Would you rather have a costume with pockets everywhere or one with an amazing cape?
- Would you rather wear a funny costume that makes everyone laugh or a spooky costume that makes everyone stare?
- Would you rather let your best friend choose your costume or choose theirs?
- Would you rather wear the same costume every Halloween or invent a new one every year?
- Would you rather have the most creative costume or the most comfortable costume?
- Would you rather dress like a classic witch or a modern witch?
- Would you rather wear a costume made from clothes you already own or build one from scratch?
- Would you rather have a costume with lights or sound effects?
- Would you rather enter a costume contest alone or with a group?
- Would you rather wear a costume that everyone recognizes or one people have to guess?
- Would you rather dress as a pumpkin or carry a giant pumpkin as your costume prop?
- Would you rather have perfect makeup or perfect hair with your costume?
- Would you rather spend your Halloween budget on your costume or your decorations?
- Would you rather have a costume that is easy to dance in or one that looks amazing in photos?
- Would you rather wear a costume that is slightly too big or slightly too small?
- Would you rather dress as something cute or something creepy?
- Would you rather have a costume picked by a random generator or by your closest friend?
- Would you rather keep your costume secret until the party or reveal it a week early?
RELATED: Halloween Paragraphs
Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Teens and Adults
Good for a mixed group when nobody wants to sit through complicated rules.
- Would you rather host the Halloween party or show up to someone else’s?
- Would you rather go to a costume party or a haunted house?
- Would you rather spend Halloween dancing all night or watching scary movies?
- Would you rather have a perfectly planned costume or make one at the last minute?
- Would you rather attend a huge Halloween party or a small night with your favorite people?
- Would you rather be in charge of the playlist or the snacks?
- Would you rather wear a costume nobody understands or one everyone loves?
- Would you rather spend the night in a crowded party or a quiet haunted-looking house?
- Would you rather have a costume that wins the contest or a party that nobody wants to leave?
- Would you rather watch a horror movie alone or with the friend who screams at everything?
- Would you rather go to a haunted corn maze or a haunted house?
- Would you rather plan the decorations or plan the food?
- Would you rather have a Halloween photo booth or a costume contest?
- Would you rather dress up with your partner or coordinate costumes with your whole friend group?
- Would you rather spend Halloween in a city or at a cozy house party?
- Would you rather have an adults-only costume party or a mixed-age neighborhood party?
- Would you rather stay out until midnight or wake up early for a Halloween breakfast?
- Would you rather have a spooky movie marathon or a Halloween game night?
- Would you rather go all in on decorations or keep the house mostly normal?
- Would you rather be remembered for your costume or for throwing the best party?
- Would you rather have a mysterious guest arrive late or your best friend arrive wearing the funniest costume?
- Would you rather host a pumpkin-carving night or a Halloween dinner?
- Would you rather have a party with a strict costume theme or complete costume freedom?
- Would you rather spend the evening taking photos or actually stay off your phone?
- Would you rather have a scary playlist or a cheesy Halloween playlist?
- Would you rather go trick-or-treating as an adult or hand out candy all night?
- Would you rather have Halloween on a Friday every year or Halloween on a Saturday every year?
- Would you rather have one great Halloween party or a whole month of small spooky plans?
- Would you rather go somewhere genuinely creepy or keep the whole night playful?
- Would you rather be the person who always hosts Halloween or the person everyone invites?
RELATED: Spooky Season Captions
Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Parties
These work better once the easy questions have warmed everyone up.
- Would you rather play Halloween trivia or Halloween charades?
- Would you rather win the costume contest or the best-decorated-house contest?
- Would you rather choose the next party game or the next song?
- Would you rather play this game sitting down or move to opposite sides of the room for each answer?
- Would you rather have one giant group game or several quick games?
- Would you rather answer every question first or always go last?
- Would you rather explain every answer or vote and move on?
- Would you rather play with your closest friends or a room full of people you just met?
- Would you rather have Halloween bingo or Halloween scavenger hunt?
- Would you rather play for candy prizes or silly plastic trophies?
- Would you rather sit next to the funniest person or the most competitive person?
- Would you rather have a spooky photo booth or a costume runway?
- Would you rather play games indoors or in the backyard?
- Would you rather have a party with a mystery theme or a classic Halloween theme?
- Would you rather have a candy bar or a dessert table at the party?
- Would you rather play Would You Rather with ten people or fifty?
- Would you rather be the host reading the questions or a player answering them?
- Would you rather have easy questions or ridiculous questions?
- Would you rather play a fast round or debate every answer?
- Would you rather get eliminated early or stay until the final question?
- Would you rather have a prize for the funniest answer or the strangest answer?
- Would you rather play a Halloween guessing game or a Halloween memory game?
- Would you rather have everyone wear matching colors or completely different costumes?
- Would you rather have a spooky playlist during the game or silence?
- Would you rather answer questions while eating candy or while holding a plastic spider?
- Would you rather have a party at home or at a rented venue?
- Would you rather start the games before dinner or after dessert?
- Would you rather have one person keep score or trust everyone to remember?
- Would you rather have a short party with nonstop games or a long party with games mixed in?
- Would you rather end the party with a scary question or a completely ridiculous one?
RELATED: Pumpkin Captions and Quotes
Really Hard Halloween Would You Rather Questions
These are the quick ones that usually start an argument before the second question.
- Would you rather give up Halloween costumes forever or Halloween candy forever?
- Would you rather never visit a haunted house again or never watch a scary movie again?
- Would you rather have your favorite costume ruined by rain or your favorite candy discontinued?
- Would you rather spend Halloween without your phone or without your favorite Halloween music?
- Would you rather wear your least favorite costume or let someone else choose one for you?
- Would you rather have to host Halloween every year or never host it again?
- Would you rather know every secret in a haunted house or never know what made the noises?
- Would you rather spend October without pumpkins or without spooky decorations?
- Would you rather only be allowed one piece of candy or one Halloween dessert?
- Would you rather have the perfect costume with nobody to party with or a simple costume with your favorite people?
- Would you rather have to walk through a haunted house backward or with the lights off?
- Would you rather hear a spooky sound every night in October or see one unexplained shadow each Halloween?
- Would you rather give away half your candy or your favorite Halloween decoration?
- Would you rather have Halloween rain every year or Halloween heat every year?
- Would you rather never carve another pumpkin or never decorate another pumpkin?
- Would you rather have your costume photographed before anyone sees it or keep it completely unposted?
- Would you rather spend Halloween night working or waking up early the next morning?
- Would you rather have a perfect party with bad food or amazing food with a boring party?
- Would you rather know your costume will be copied or know nobody else will understand it?
- Would you rather have a haunted house next door or a cemetery across the street?
- Would you rather have one spooky mystery you can never solve or one silly mystery everyone thinks is real?
- Would you rather lose your costume shoes or your candy bucket halfway through the night?
- Would you rather give up pumpkins or black cats as Halloween symbols?
- Would you rather have to plan every detail of Halloween or leave every detail to chance?
- Would you rather spend all of October in costume or save dressing up for one night?
- Would you rather have a party where nobody arrives in costume or one where everyone takes the theme too seriously?
- Would you rather have one amazing Halloween memory or a hundred funny little ones?
- Would you rather always get the best candy or always have the best costume?
- Would you rather have a creepy house that is actually harmless or a normal house with one unexplained spooky detail?
- Would you rather answer one impossible Halloween question or ten easy ones?
RELATED: Ghost Captions and Quotes
How to Play Halloween Would You Rather
You do not need cards, a board, or anything to print. Read one question, let everyone pick a side, and then ask a few people to explain themselves. The explanation is usually funnier than the answer.
- Have everyone hold up one finger for the first choice and two fingers for the second.
- For a bigger party, put one choice on each side of the room and let everyone move to their answer.
- Give people a few seconds to choose before anyone tries to influence the room.
- Ask two or three players why they picked their answer when the question is especially close.
- Keep the younger kids on the silly, candy, pumpkin, and costume questions.
- Save the creepier questions for teens and adults who actually want the spooky part.
- Use the questions between other party activities when you need something that requires no setup.
- For a classroom, let students vote quietly with their hands before calling on anyone.
- For a family game night, let the person with the most surprising answer choose the next question.
For a darker game night, Haunted House Captions and Quotes has more eerie wording. If people are posting their party photos, our Halloween Hashtags page can help with that part.
You can also use one or two questions as table cards, write them on a chalkboard, or keep them in your phone for those quiet minutes when everyone is looking for the next thing to do. For more general Halloween message ideas, Halloween Wishes has another batch of wording to borrow from.
Save this list before October gets busy. The best questions are the ones that make someone immediately say, wait, that is actually hard.
For the morning before the party, Halloween Good Morning Wishes can help with a quick seasonal text.
If you liked this, you will like these too:
More Halloween ideas:
