200+ Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Kids
Would You Rather gets especially funny with kids because they can turn a completely imaginary choice into a very serious debate.
This list is made specifically for Halloween and specifically for kids. The choices stay clean and playful, with lots of candy, costumes, pumpkins, crafts, trick-or-treating, school activities, and harmless spooky ideas.
It is also different from our general Halloween Would You Rather article. That page covers a wider age range, including teen and adult questions and creepier party scenarios. This one stays firmly in the kids lane.
For more kid-friendly Halloween ideas, see Halloween Quotes for Kids and Halloween Party Invitation Wording.
Table of Contents
Easy Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Kids
Simple choices for younger kids and mixed-age groups.
- Would you rather wear pumpkin socks or bat socks?
- Would you rather decorate a pumpkin with dots or stars?
- Would you rather make a paper ghost or a paper spider?
- Would you rather eat a candy apple or caramel popcorn?
- Would you rather visit a pumpkin patch or a Halloween craft fair?
- Would you rather have a pumpkin backpack or a bat lunchbox?
- Would you rather choose the Halloween music or the Halloween snacks?
- Would you rather paint a pumpkin blue or purple?
- Would you rather wear a cape or a giant hat?
- Would you rather have glow-in-the-dark shoes or glow-in-the-dark pajamas?
- Would you rather make a spooky drawing or a spooky story?
- Would you rather have a friendly ghost next door or a friendly witch next door?
- Would you rather decorate your bedroom or the front door?
- Would you rather find a treat under your pillow or inside your backpack?
- Would you rather wear an animal costume or a superhero costume?
- Would you rather make a pumpkin face or a monster face?
- Would you rather have a tiny broom or a tiny cauldron for your desk?
- Would you rather have orange hair for a day or purple hair for a day?
- Would you rather make Halloween cookies or Halloween cupcakes?
- Would you rather have pumpkin lights or star lights in your room?
- Would you rather see a giant pumpkin or a giant pile of leaves?
- Would you rather have a candy bucket with your name on it or a funny face on it?
- Would you rather make a Halloween card or a Halloween sign?
- Would you rather spend Halloween playing games or making crafts?
- Would you rather have a friendly bat or a friendly owl visit your yard?
RELATED: Halloween Chalkboard Quotes
Funny Halloween Would You Rather Questions for Kids
These are meant to get laughs without making the choices too complicated.
- Would you rather have a pumpkin that giggles or a candy bag that sings?
- Would you rather sneeze bubbles or hiccup tiny bats?
- Would you rather have candy corn for buttons or gummy worms for shoelaces?
- Would you rather wear a pumpkin hat that is too big or monster gloves that are too small?
- Would you rather talk like a robot or walk like a penguin whenever someone says Halloween?
- Would you rather have a ghost who tells terrible jokes or a skeleton who dances nonstop?
- Would you rather wear two different Halloween shoes or two different Halloween socks?
- Would you rather have a witch give you snack advice or a vampire remind you to brush your teeth?
- Would you rather carry a giant lollipop or a giant candy cane all night?
- Would you rather have your costume announce your name or announce your favorite candy?
- Would you rather have a pumpkin helmet or a bat backpack?
- Would you rather have a ghost who sneezes glitter or a monster who hiccups bubbles?
- Would you rather have a sticker stuck to your forehead or a candy wrapper stuck to your shoe?
- Would you rather hop three times before saying trick or treat or spin once?
- Would you rather have a pumpkin that laughs or a broom that tells jokes?
- Would you rather have a skeleton coach your soccer team or a mummy coach your dance team?
- Would you rather have your candy bucket ask for snacks or your costume ask for compliments?
- Would you rather make a monster noise when you sneeze or a witch laugh when you yawn?
- Would you rather decorate your room with 50 bats or 50 eyeballs?
- Would you rather have a jack-o’-lantern with giant eyebrows or giant teeth?
- Would you rather be followed by one polite zombie or three confused ghosts?
- Would you rather greet everyone with boo or happy hauntings?
- Would you rather wear a balloon costume or a feather costume?
- Would you rather have squeaky boots or a squeaky broom?
- Would you rather have a candy bag that laughs or a pumpkin that whispers?
RELATED: Pumpkin Captions and Quotes
Halloween Candy Would You Rather Questions for Kids
The candy questions are usually where strong opinions appear fast.
- Would you rather double your favorite candy or try three new candies?
- Would you rather have a candy bracelet or candy necklace?
- Would you rather choose five small treats or one giant mystery treat?
- Would you rather have chocolate coins or gummy fruit?
- Would you rather eat something crunchy or something chewy?
- Would you rather get a caramel apple or caramel popcorn?
- Would you rather have a candy bucket with secret compartments or one huge opening?
- Would you rather trade one piece with every friend or keep everything?
- Would you rather have your favorite candy in every color or one giant piece?
- Would you rather build a candy tower or a candy road?
- Would you rather eat sour candy or super-chewy candy?
- Would you rather have bat-shaped candy or pumpkin-shaped candy?
- Would you rather find an extra treat in every pocket or at home?
- Would you rather pick your first candy or your last candy?
- Would you rather have a bowl filled with surprises or favorites?
- Would you rather have a chocolate pretzel or chocolate cookie?
- Would you rather have gummy bears or chocolate buttons?
- Would you rather enter a candy sorting contest or candy guessing contest?
- Would you rather invent a candy flavor or a candy shape?
- Would you rather have candy that crackles or changes color?
- Would you rather save your best treat for later or eat it first?
- Would you rather have no duplicate candy or lots of your favorite?
- Would you rather decorate a cupcake or cookie with candy?
- Would you rather have treats delivered by robot or tiny wagon?
- Would you rather sort candy by color or shape?
RELATED: Trick or Treat Captions
Halloween Costume Would You Rather Questions for Kids
Costume decisions get much easier when they are completely imaginary.
- Would you rather dress as a deep-sea diver or astronaut?
- Would you rather have a giant tail or giant ears on your costume?
- Would you rather be a friendly dragon or a funny robot?
- Would you rather have glowing gloves or glowing shoes?
- Would you rather have pockets everywhere or one giant hood?
- Would you rather build your costume from cardboard or fabric?
- Would you rather have a costume that changes color when you clap or spin?
- Would you rather dress as a storybook hero or invent a new character?
- Would you rather have a moving hat or moving backpack?
- Would you rather have a costume with a tiny sound or no sound at all?
- Would you rather dress as a forest animal or ocean animal?
- Would you rather have a cape covered in stars or moons?
- Would you rather add a magic button or magic zipper to your costume?
- Would you rather have an orange costume or purple costume?
- Would you rather wear a mask that changes expressions or a hat that changes shape?
- Would you rather choose a family costume or family costume colors?
- Would you rather have wings or a long scarf?
- Would you rather dress as a candy detective or potion inventor?
- Would you rather have an easy costume or one with lots of tiny details?
- Would you rather have stars or pumpkins all over your costume?
- Would you rather have a costume that looks best far away or up close?
- Would you rather get ready in five minutes or one hour?
- Would you rather design a costume for yourself or your pet?
- Would you rather dress as something from a book or something you invented?
- Would you rather have a secret pocket or secret button?
RELATED: Halloween Card Messages for Kids
Pumpkin and Decorating Would You Rather Questions for Kids
Good for kids who would happily decorate every pumpkin in sight.
- Would you rather paint a pumpkin with polka dots or zigzags?
- Would you rather carve a happy face or surprised face?
- Would you rather decorate ten tiny pumpkins or one huge pumpkin?
- Would you rather put your pumpkin by the door or window?
- Would you rather have pumpkin lights or hanging paper bats?
- Would you rather make a display with flowers or fall leaves?
- Would you rather decorate with orange and purple or green and black?
- Would you rather have a pumpkin that talks or changes color?
- Would you rather make a pumpkin family or pumpkin monster?
- Would you rather use paint or stickers?
- Would you rather make a giant paper spider or ghost?
- Would you rather have a porch full of pumpkins or lanterns?
- Would you rather decorate the snack table or front door?
- Would you rather give your pumpkin a silly face or animal face?
- Would you rather use colorful ribbons or paper shapes?
- Would you rather make a spooky table or silly table?
- Would you rather make a garland of ghosts or pumpkins?
- Would you rather have decorations that move in the breeze or glow after dark?
- Would you rather decorate a pumpkin like a cat or monster?
- Would you rather make a sign for the door or snack table?
- Would you rather use real pumpkins or paper pumpkins?
- Would you rather make a leaf collage or pumpkin collage?
- Would you rather paint a moon or stars on your pumpkin?
- Would you rather have one huge jack-o’-lantern or many tiny ones?
- Would you rather decorate with your family or your friends?
RELATED: Halloween Letter Board Quotes
Spooky but Not-Too-Scary Would You Rather Questions
A little mystery, but nothing that should ruin bedtime.
- Would you rather hear a friendly ghost say good morning or a friendly monster say good night?
- Would you rather follow glowing footprints or floating leaves?
- Would you rather open a door to a moonlit garden or room of glowing pumpkins?
- Would you rather find a tiny skeleton key or an old map?
- Would you rather hear a knock in the attic or a squeak downstairs?
- Would you rather find a hidden pumpkin room or spooky library?
- Would you rather meet a ghost who tells jokes or mummy who tells riddles?
- Would you rather explore a foggy garden or brightly lit spooky room?
- Would you rather see a pumpkin blink or a portrait wink?
- Would you rather find a mysterious note or tiny footprint?
- Would you rather have a friendly shadow follow you or a floating lantern guide you?
- Would you rather hear a wind chime at midnight or watch a curtain move?
- Would you rather find a secret stairway or secret door?
- Would you rather explore a pretend haunted library or museum?
- Would you rather hear footsteps that turn out to be a cat or a squeaky door?
- Would you rather enter a room glowing blue or orange?
- Would you rather find an old costume trunk or decoration box?
- Would you rather walk past friendly scarecrows or lanterns?
- Would you rather have a tiny ghost friend or tiny bat friend?
- Would you rather solve a missing pumpkin mystery or missing candy mystery?
- Would you rather have a magic mirror or magic door?
- Would you rather spend Halloween in a cozy attic or pumpkin-filled room?
- Would you rather hear a strange kitchen noise or closet noise?
- Would you rather find glowing footprints or floating candy wrappers?
- Would you rather see a friendly witch fly past or friendly ghost wave?
RELATED: Halloween Wishes
Trick-or-Treat Would You Rather Questions for Kids
Use these while kids are getting ready or waiting to head outside.
- Would you rather visit ten houses with huge decorations or twenty with simple ones?
- Would you rather carry a pumpkin bucket or tote bag?
- Would you rather trick-or-treat with your best friend or whole family?
- Would you rather start at sunset or just before dark?
- Would you rather visit a house with glowing pumpkins or giant inflatable monster?
- Would you rather hear a silly song at every house or a different spooky sound?
- Would you rather collect treats from porches or a neighborhood treat table?
- Would you rather wear comfy shoes or your favorite costume boots?
- Would you rather carry a star flashlight or pumpkin flashlight?
- Would you rather get one candy at every house or pick three at the end?
- Would you rather walk on a costume-filled street or decoration-filled street?
- Would you rather see a pumpkin patch or giant leaf pile on your route?
- Would you rather stop for a snack halfway or wait until home?
- Would you rather have a secret pocket in your candy bag or glow strap?
- Would you rather trick-or-treat as a pirate or astronaut?
- Would you rather visit houses with spooky music or funny music?
- Would you rather ring every doorbell or say trick or treat?
- Would you rather walk a short route twice or long route once?
- Would you rather see the biggest pumpkin or funniest costume?
- Would you rather get treats from a candy chute or decorated wagon?
- Would you rather trade candy before getting home or after?
- Would you rather have a grown-up carry the flashlight or candy bag?
- Would you rather collect mostly chocolate or fruity treats?
- Would you rather visit a castle-themed house or spaceship-themed house?
- Would you rather count your candy right away or next morning?
RELATED: Halloween Puns
Halloween Party and School Would You Rather Questions
Easy choices for a classroom, playdate, or family party.
- Would you rather win a pumpkin contest or costume contest?
- Would you rather play a guessing game or drawing game?
- Would you rather make a spooky craft or decorate a cupcake?
- Would you rather have a pumpkin party or monster party?
- Would you rather sit at a table covered in bats or pumpkins?
- Would you rather choose the first game or last game?
- Would you rather have a treasure hunt or relay race?
- Would you rather make a group costume craft or group decoration?
- Would you rather read the questions or answer first?
- Would you rather play in teams of two or four?
- Would you rather have a snack table or dessert table?
- Would you rather have a photo corner or craft corner?
- Would you rather make paper pumpkins or paper monsters?
- Would you rather have a dance contest or costume walk?
- Would you rather sit beside the funniest friend or most competitive friend?
- Would you rather have the party indoors or under a covered outdoor space?
- Would you rather play a five-minute game or twenty-minute game?
- Would you rather have tiny prizes for everyone or one big prize?
- Would you rather choose party music or decorations?
- Would you rather have a mystery craft box or mystery treat box?
- Would you rather start with a craft or a game?
- Would you rather have a class mascot that is a bat or black cat?
- Would you rather solve Halloween word puzzles or picture puzzles?
- Would you rather make a Halloween bookmark or greeting card?
- Would you rather end with a group photo or final game?
Impossible Halloween Choices for Kids
These get deliberately ridiculous once the ordinary Halloween choices run out.
- Would you rather have every pumpkin you touch turn into a toy or every leaf turn into a sticker?
- Would you rather shrink to candy-corn size or grow as tall as a pumpkin for an hour?
- Would you rather have a tiny dragon or tiny ghost as a helper?
- Would you rather make costumes come alive for ten minutes or pumpkins tell jokes?
- Would you rather have a magic candy bag or endless costume closet?
- Would you rather jump over a house or run as fast as a bat?
- Would you rather have a tiny moon follow you or tiny pumpkin?
- Would you rather spend Halloween in a candy castle or pumpkin castle?
- Would you rather make it rain wrapped candy or confetti pumpkins?
- Would you rather turn chores into games or homework into drawing?
- Would you rather wake up with enchanted shoes or pajamas?
- Would you rather have a broom that finds lost toys or cauldron that makes cocoa?
- Would you rather have a friendly monster as principal or witch as teacher?
- Would you rather talk to pumpkins or bats?
- Would you rather own a tiny pumpkin farm or costume workshop?
- Would you rather turn sandwiches into Halloween sandwiches or drinks into spooky colors?
- Would you rather have a moon-shaped window or pumpkin-shaped door?
- Would you rather see hidden candy or hear hidden candy?
- Would you rather have a backpack that refills snacks or shoes that refill energy?
- Would you rather find a Halloween planet or island?
- Would you rather make one giant jack-o’-lantern glow or 100 tiny ones glow briefly?
- Would you rather own a talking pumpkin patch or costume shop?
- Would you rather have a ghost who freezes time for five seconds or bat who flies anywhere?
- Would you rather make drawings float or toys tell stories?
- Would you rather have Halloween every month or make October twice as long?
How to Play Halloween Would You Rather With Kids
Keep the rules loose and let the explanations do most of the work.
- Read one choice aloud and give everyone a few seconds to pick.
- Have kids point left or right for their answer.
- For a larger group, put each choice on opposite sides of the room.
- Ask a few kids why they chose their answer when the group splits.
- Let younger children answer together if they do not want to speak alone.
- In a classroom, write A and B on the board and let students vote.
- Use ten questions for a quick activity or a whole section for a longer game.
- Mix easy questions with silly ones so nobody gets bored.
- Skip any question the group does not like.
- Let kids invent a third answer when they have a funny idea.
- Use the trick-or-treat section while everyone is waiting to head outside.
- Save the impossible questions for the end when everyone is warmed up.
There is no score you have to keep. The fun usually comes from the explanations, the arguments over candy, and the kid who somehow chooses an answer nobody else considered.
Save the list before your next Halloween party, school celebration, playdate, or family night. You can pick a different section each time and never have to come up with the questions yourself.
For more Halloween game-adjacent ideas, browse Halloween Puns or Halloween Wishes.
If you liked this, you will like these too:
